“Somewhere, something incredible is waiting to be known.” ― Carl Sagan Current Biology

9th October 2013

Photo with 41 notes

I, too, find this to be ethically problematic (and yucky!)
Cyborg Cockroach Company Sparks Ethics Debate (Wired)
At the TEDx conference in Detroit last week, RoboRoach #12 scuttled across the exhibition floor, pursued not by an exterminator but by a gaggle of fascinated onlookers. Wearing a tiny backpack of microelectronics on its shell, the cockroach—a member of the Blaptica dubia species—zigzagged along the corridor in a twitchy fashion, its direction controlled by the brush of a finger against an iPhone touch screen.
RoboRoach #12 and its brethren are billed as a do-it-yourself neuroscience experiment that allows students to create their own “cyborg” insects. The roach was the main feature of the TEDx talk by Greg Gage and Tim Marzullo, co-founders of an educational company called Backyard Brains. After a summer Kickstarter campaign raised enough money to let them hone their insect creation, the pair used the Detroit presentation to show it off and announce that starting in November, the company will, for $99, begin shipping live cockroaches across the nation, accompanied by a microelectronic hardware and surgical kits geared toward students as young as 10 years old.
That news, however, hasn’t been greeted warmly by everyone. Gage and Marzullo, both trained as neuroscientists and engineers, say that the purpose of the project is to spur a “neuro-revolution” by inspiring more kids to join the fields when they grow up, but some critics say the project is sending the wrong message. “They encourage amateurs to operate invasively on living organisms” and “encourage thinking of complex living organisms as mere machines or tools,” says Michael Allen Fox, a professor of philosophy at Queen’s University in Kingston, Canada.
Backyard Brains poster. Image: Jason Tester/Guerilla Futures/Flickr

I, too, find this to be ethically problematic (and yucky!)

Cyborg Cockroach Company Sparks Ethics Debate (Wired)

At the TEDx conference in Detroit last week, RoboRoach #12 scuttled across the exhibition floor, pursued not by an exterminator but by a gaggle of fascinated onlookers. Wearing a tiny backpack of microelectronics on its shell, the cockroach—a member of the Blaptica dubia species—zigzagged along the corridor in a twitchy fashion, its direction controlled by the brush of a finger against an iPhone touch screen.

RoboRoach #12 and its brethren are billed as a do-it-yourself neuroscience experiment that allows students to create their own “cyborg” insects. The roach was the main feature of the TEDx talk by Greg Gage and Tim Marzullo, co-founders of an educational company called Backyard Brains. After a summer Kickstarter campaign raised enough money to let them hone their insect creation, the pair used the Detroit presentation to show it off and announce that starting in November, the company will, for $99, begin shipping live cockroaches across the nation, accompanied by a microelectronic hardware and surgical kits geared toward students as young as 10 years old.

That news, however, hasn’t been greeted warmly by everyone. Gage and Marzullo, both trained as neuroscientists and engineers, say that the purpose of the project is to spur a “neuro-revolution” by inspiring more kids to join the fields when they grow up, but some critics say the project is sending the wrong message. “They encourage amateurs to operate invasively on living organisms” and “encourage thinking of complex living organisms as mere machines or tools,” says Michael Allen Fox, a professor of philosophy at Queen’s University in Kingston, Canada.

Backyard Brains poster. Image: Jason Tester/Guerilla Futures/Flickr

Tagged: NeuroscienceKitsCockroachescyborgBiologyScienceBioethics

()

  1. tenerelupumaribus reblogged this from goulbournes
  2. akzidens reblogged this from currentsinbiology
  3. savetheplanarians reblogged this from currentsinbiology
  4. pizzaxpunkx reblogged this from currentsinbiology
  5. uwcdoverbiosoc reblogged this from currentsinbiology
  6. viirulentscience reblogged this from currentsinbiology
  7. laska-the-wookie reblogged this from currentsinbiology
  8. bandit1a reblogged this from currentsinbiology
  9. in-a-limousine said: They’re just cockroaches!
  10. yincira reblogged this from currentsinbiology
  11. premiumbounce reblogged this from currentsinbiology and added:
    I’m on team robot cockroach. I tend to agree with this statement “Gage says that in his experience, working carefully...
  12. margieandlala reblogged this from currentsinbiology and added:
    I want one….
  13. eating-planets reblogged this from currentsinbiology and added:
    I feel for you cyborg bugs
  14. blastinfatnic reblogged this from currentsinbiology and added:
    Whaaat
  15. farms-over-boys reblogged this from currentsinbiology
  16. feignedaffections reblogged this from currentsinbiology and added:
    Hurray! Let’s cheer for the gatekeepers of science. Let’s not encourage people to develop an interest in science. I mean...
  17. actualmichelle reblogged this from currentsinbiology and added:
    yeah, wow. This is just terrible.
  18. taringitup reblogged this from currentsinbiology
  19. spiritthatdenies reblogged this from currentsinbiology
  20. crawclaw reblogged this from currentsinbiology
  21. kikiavicenna reblogged this from currentsinbiology
  22. sugarysnarks reblogged this from currentsinbiology
  23. currentsinbiology posted this